Why your bath sealant keeps going black, and the proper fix
Black sealant is not dirt. It is mould growing in and under silicone that has lost its seal, which is why cleaning it never works for long.
It is one of the most common jobs we are asked about, and one of the most commonly bodged. A bead of silicone around a bath or shower tray goes black at the edges, somebody scrubs it, it comes back, somebody runs a new bead over the top of it, and six months later it is worse than before.
What is actually happening
Silicone is waterproof, but the joint it sits in moves. A bath full of water and a person is a lot heavier than an empty bath, and it flexes downwards by a surprising amount. Every time that happens, the bead is stretched. Eventually it parts company with the bath, the tile, or both, in places you cannot see. Water then gets behind it and stays there, and the mould you can see at the surface is growing in the damp gap behind the silicone rather than on it.
That is why cleaning does not fix it. You are cleaning the visible end of a problem that lives behind the bead. And it is why new silicone on top of old never works: silicone does not bond to cured silicone, so you have simply put a lid on a wet, mouldy gap.
What proper resealing involves
There is no shortcut, and the whole job is in the preparation.
- Cut the old bead out completely. All of it, including the thin smear left behind, using a sealant knife and a solvent remover rather than brute force.
- Clean and kill the mould. A mould treatment, left to work, then rinsed.
- Dry the joint fully. This is the step people skip. Silicone applied onto a damp joint fails early, and a joint that has been wet behind the bead for years needs more than ten minutes.
- Fill the bath before sealing, where it is right to do so. Sealing under load means the joint is at its widest when the silicone cures, so it is not stretched to breaking the first time somebody gets in.
- Use a mould-resistant sanitary silicone, not a general-purpose or frame sealant, and run it as one continuous bead rather than in sections.
- Leave it alone to cure. At least 24 hours before it gets wet, and the tube will say what it needs. This is the second step people skip, and it undoes everything above it.
Why the corners should never be grouted
While we are here: internal corners, and the junction between tiles and a bath, worktop or tray, should be silicone, not grout. Those joints move, grout is rigid, so it cracks, and then water gets behind the tiles. If your bathroom has grouted corners that keep cracking and going black, that is the reason, and swapping grout for sealant in those joints is a straightforward job that solves it permanently.
How to make it last
Ventilate. The single biggest factor in how long sealant and grout stay clean is how fast the room dries after a shower. Use the extractor fan, and check it actually vents outside rather than into the loft, which we find more often than you would believe. Open the window. Wipe the edge of the bath or the screen down occasionally. And if there is no fan, that is a worthwhile thing to have fitted by an electrician, because everything else in the bathroom lasts longer once the room dries properly.
When it is more than sealant
If there is a stain on the ceiling below, or the floor feels soft near the bath, the water has been getting through for a while and the repair is no longer cosmetic. Stop and get it looked at before resealing, because sealing over an active leak just hides it. The same goes for tiles that sound hollow when tapped: water behind the tiles has already loosened the adhesive, and new silicone at the edge will not change that.
Questions people ask
Can I just clean black sealant?
How long before I can use the shower after resealing?
Should the corners be grouted or sealed?
Why does my bathroom sealant go black so fast?
More from the blog
-
19 Nov 2026
Ten jobs worth doing before winter in a Cardiff house
None of these are glamorous and all of them are cheap. Every one of them prevents something that costs real money if it is left until...
-
13 Nov 2026
Loft boarding without ruining your insulation
Boarding a loft the usual way squashes 270mm of insulation down to 100mm. You get storage and quietly lose a third of what the insulation...
-
1 Nov 2026
Damp patches: what usually causes them in older Cardiff houses
Rising damp exists, but it is diagnosed far more often than it occurs. Six ordinary things explain most of the damp patches we are asked to...